Guide

Common Debt Recovery Mistakes and How to Avoid Them

Ten mistakes businesses make when chasing unpaid invoices, grouped by the stage at which they happen: why each one occurs, what it costs, the warning sign that you are making it, and what to do instead.

By HK Commercial Debt Recovery Published 5 November 2026 Updated 7 November 2026
10 mistakes in three stagesWhat each one costs youA warning sign for eachQuick read
Why it matters

Every mistake costs you one of three things

Most problems with unpaid invoices come from the process, not the debt. Each of the ten mistakes below costs time, leverage or money, and usually more than one.

TimeOld debts are harder to collect. Every week of delay lowers the chance of being paid in full.
LeverageKeep supplying, or make a threat you do not act on, and the customer has less reason to pay.
MoneyThe wrong route costs fees and time, and interest you were owed goes unclaimed.
6 yearsThe limitation period in England and Wales. The practical window for recovering in full is measured in weeks.
  1. Setting upTerms, identity and credit checks. Mistakes 1 to 3.The aimKnow who you are dealing with and on what terms.
  2. ChasingTiming, method and supply. Mistakes 4 to 6.The aimMake paying you the path of least resistance.
  3. EscalatingThreats, letters, court and interest. Mistakes 7 to 10.The aimEscalate in the right order against a debtor who can pay.
Setting up · mistakes 1 to 3

Before you supply

Three mistakes made before an invoice is even raised. They are the cheapest to fix and the most expensive to ignore, because everything that follows rests on them.

The aimKnow who you are dealing with, on what terms, and how much credit you can afford to give them.
  1. Mistake 1

    Trading without written terms

    Work starts on a call or a handshake, especially with customers you know.

    Warning signYou cannot find anything the customer signed or replied to that says when they will pay.

    What it costs you

    With no agreed payment date, the customer can argue about when the invoice was due, and you have nothing in writing to rely on if it is disputed.

    Do this instead

    • Get your terms accepted in writing before the first order, even if only by email.
    • State the payment date, your right to interest and costs, and when ownership of goods passes.
    • If nothing was agreed, rely on the legal default: payment is generally due 30 days after delivery or the invoice, whichever is later.
  2. Mistake 2

    Not knowing exactly who owes you

    The customer trades under a brand name, and the invoice is made out to that rather than the company or person behind it.

    Warning signYour invoice says a trading name and you are not sure whether it is a limited company.

    What it costs you

    A demand or claim against the wrong name can fail or have to start again. It also decides which rules apply: a sole trader is treated differently from a limited company.

    Do this instead

    • Record the full legal name, company number and registered office when you open the account.
    • Check the details against Companies House.
    • Put the legal name on every invoice, not just the trading name.
  3. Mistake 3

    Giving credit without checking

    Winning the order feels more urgent than checking whether the customer can pay for it.

    Warning signA new customer's first order is large and you have not looked at their accounts.

    What it costs you

    You find out about their finances only after you have supplied, when the invoice is already overdue.

    Do this instead

    • Credit check new customers and set a limit you can afford to have outstanding.
    • Ask new or weaker customers for a deposit or staged payments.
    • Review the limit when their payment habits change.
Chasing · mistakes 4 to 6

Once it is overdue

Three mistakes in the first weeks after the due date, when a debt is most collectable and most businesses do least.

The aimMake paying you the path of least resistance, and find out early if something is wrong.
  1. Mistake 4

    Waiting too long to chase

    Nobody wants to upset a good customer, and chasing slips behind the day job.

    Warning signInvoices sit 30 days past due before anyone picks up the phone.

    What it costs you

    The older a debt gets, the harder it is to collect. The customer also learns that paying you late has no consequence.

    Do this instead

    • Chase the day after the due date, every time.
    • Follow a fixed timetable: reminder, phone call, final demand, decision.
    • Treat the first broken promise as a warning sign, not a one-off.
  2. Mistake 5

    Chasing only by email

    Email feels less awkward than a phone call.

    Warning signYou have sent three reminders and had no reply to any of them.

    What it costs you

    Emails are easy to ignore, and you never find out the real reason for the delay or who actually decides when you are paid.

    Do this instead

    • Phone first, then confirm what was agreed by email.
    • Ask for the person who approves payments, not just your usual contact.
    • Keep a dated note of every call.
  3. Mistake 6

    Carrying on supplying

    Stopping supply feels like ending the relationship.

    Warning signThe overdue balance is bigger this month than last, and you are still delivering.

    What it costs you

    The debt grows with every delivery, and you give away the strongest reason the customer has to pay you.

    Do this instead

    • Put the account on stop once an invoice is overdue.
    • Offer to resume on payment, or on cash up front until the account is clear.
    • Check your contract first if you are committed to ongoing supply.
Escalating · mistakes 7 to 10

When chasing has not worked

Four mistakes in how businesses move from chasing to formal recovery. Each one either weakens your position or spends money for nothing.

The aimEscalate in the right order, with the right evidence, against a debtor who can actually pay.
  1. Mistake 7

    Making threats you do not carry out

    It is tempting to hope the threat alone will do the job.

    Warning signYou have sent more than one "final" demand to the same customer.

    What it costs you

    Once a deadline passes and nothing happens, your next demand carries no weight. Repeated or aggressive threats can also amount to harassment.

    Do this instead

    • Only state steps you are prepared to take.
    • Give one clear deadline, in writing.
    • Act the day after it passes.
  2. Mistake 8

    Skipping the Letter Before Action

    After months of chasing, going straight to court feels overdue.

    Warning signYou are about to issue a claim and the last thing the customer received was a statement.

    What it costs you

    Courts expect a proper warning first. Without one, a claim can be delayed and you can be penalised on costs, even if you win.

    Do this instead

    • Send a formal letter setting out the debt, the evidence and a deadline.
    • Allow a reasonable time to respond. For a sole trader or individual the formal period is 30 days.
    • Keep proof of when and how it was sent.
  3. Mistake 9

    Suing a customer who cannot pay

    The debt is clearly owed, so court action feels like a matter of principle.

    Warning signTheir accounts are overdue at Companies House, or other suppliers are chasing too.

    What it costs you

    You pay court fees and spend months obtaining a judgment against a business with no money or assets to meet it.

    Do this instead

    • Check the customer is still trading and look for signs of insolvency first.
    • Weigh the likely recovery against the cost of each route.
    • Decide whether the debt is worth pursuing before you commit to court.
  4. Mistake 10

    Leaving interest and compensation unclaimed

    Many businesses do not know they are entitled to it, or feel awkward asking.

    Warning signYour final demand is for the invoice total and nothing else.

    What it costs you

    Statutory interest at 8% above the Bank of England base rate and £40 to £100 per late invoice goes unclaimed, and you lose a useful lever in negotiation.

    Do this instead

    • Work out interest and compensation on every overdue invoice.
    • Include both in the final demand and the Letter Before Action.
    • Decide later whether to waive them in return for prompt payment.
Quick reference

The ten fixes on one page

Each mistake and its fix in a line. Print it, pin it above the ledger.

#
The mistake
The fix
Setting up
1
Trading without written terms
Terms accepted in writing before the first order
2
Not knowing exactly who owes you
Legal name and company number on every invoice
3
Giving credit without checking
Credit check, credit limit, deposit where needed
Chasing
4
Waiting too long to chase
Reminder the day after the due date, every time
5
Chasing only by email
Phone first, confirm by email, note the date
6
Carrying on supplying
Account on stop once overdue
Escalating
7
Making threats you do not carry out
One deadline in writing, then act on it
8
Skipping the Letter Before Action
Formal letter with evidence and a reasonable deadline
9
Suing a customer who cannot pay
Check solvency and weigh recovery against cost first
10
Leaving interest and compensation unclaimed
Add interest and compensation to every demand
The fix

A process that avoids all ten

Four habits, in order. Each one closes off the mistakes above.

  1. Set up properly

    • Written terms accepted
    • Legal name and company number recorded
    • Credit check and credit limit

    Avoids: mistakes 1 to 3

  2. Chase on time

    • A reminder the day after the due date
    • A phone call, confirmed by email
    • A dated note of every contact

    Avoids: mistakes 4 and 5

  3. Hold your position

    • Account on stop when overdue
    • One deadline, in writing
    • Action when it passes

    Avoids: mistakes 6 and 7

  4. Escalate with care

    • Check the customer can pay
    • Send a Letter Before Action
    • Add interest and compensation

    Avoids: mistakes 8 to 10

Know your limits

When to get a second opinion

Plenty of debts can be recovered in-house. These are the signs that an outside view would help, and the point at which a commercial agency usually recovers more for less risk than carrying on alone.

Fine to handle yourself

  • The invoice is only recently overdue
  • The customer is answering and giving dates
  • Any query is specific and can be fixed
  • You know exactly who owes you

Worth a second opinion

  • Your reminders and calls have not produced a payment date
  • A promise has been broken
  • You are thinking about court action
  • The customer may be in financial difficulty
  • You are not sure the debt is worth pursuing

Related: Late payment excuses and how to answer them · How to recover an unpaid invoice · Our process

Common questions

Common questions about recovering unpaid debts

What is the biggest mistake businesses make with unpaid invoices?

Waiting too long. Chasing often starts weeks after the due date, by which time the customer has learned that paying late has no consequence and the debt is harder to collect. Start the day after the invoice falls due.

How long do I have to recover a business debt?

In England and Wales a claim for a simple contract debt must generally be started within six years of the debt falling due; in Scotland it is five years. Evidence and options both fade well before then, so act early.

Do I have to send a Letter Before Action before going to court?

In practice, yes. Courts expect you to set out the claim and give the debtor a reasonable chance to respond before you issue proceedings, and can penalise you on costs if you do not. Where the debtor is an individual or sole trader, a formal protocol applies with a 30-day response period.

Can I recover the cost of chasing a debt?

Partly. On a late business-to-business invoice you can claim fixed compensation of £40, £70 or £100, plus reasonable recovery costs above that sum where you can evidence them. Court fees are normally added to a claim, but the legal costs you can recover on smaller claims are limited.

Is it a mistake to use a debt recovery agency?

Not for a business debt that is overdue and going nowhere. An agency working on a no win, no fee basis costs nothing if it does not recover, usually moves a debtor that has stopped responding to you, and gives you an honest view on whether court action is worth it. The mistake is leaving it until the debt is old.

Keep going

Where next

Where a debt goes from here, and the other tools worth running.

Want the debt handled properly from here?

Send us the debt for a free case review. We look at the account history, the paperwork and the commercial position, and come back to you within one working day with a recommended next step.

Free case review within one working day. B2B debts only. Genuine no win, no fee: no set-up or administration fees, and no commission unless we recover for you.